Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Andrew LiVecchi's avatar

Yes, I think you're right, Scott. The Victorians were foundational to the study of ancient and medieval cultures, but they brought in many unhelpful assumptions.

I do also find it interesting how little we know about Celtic paganism. Irish mythology, which we have the most evidence for, is first written down by medieval monks, who obviously didn't share the beliefs of their pagan ancestors. It's a similar challenge to disentangling all the interpretative layers surrounding Viking religious beliefs.

Fr. Scott Bailey, C.Ss.R.'s avatar

Thank you. You bring up an important point: that our knowledge of the ancient Celts doesn’t come from the Celts themselves but from others writing about them. I’m not sure how true it is, but it seems to me that a lot of what people think about the Celts was invented by the Victorian antiquarians and to a lesser extent their predecessors in the 18th century. For instance there is little real historical evidence concerning their religious beliefs but don’t say that to a neopagan. I wonder just how much “history” was created in the Victorian era.

No posts

Ready for more?